Unbiased MyProtein The Whey Review

Welcome to my MyProtein The Whey Review. MyProtein markets The Whey as a premium protein powder, claiming it offers quality comparable to industry leaders like ON Gold Standard Whey. However, upon closer inspection, it’s evident that MyPro The Whey Protein may not live up to its claims. The likely inclusion of amino spiking and low-quality protein sources—such as hydrolyzed collagen—raises questions about its value. Keep reading to understand why MyProtein The Whey falls short of expectations.

🌟 As a certified strength and conditioning expert (NSCA) and nutrition specialist (CISSN), I’m here to give you straightforward, no-nonsense reviews, including using MyPro The Whey Vanilla Ice Cream in my routine. 

👥 I review products based on your requests and my personal interests—no sponsorships, no brand influence. My reviews are rooted in product quality alone, and I’m not afraid to call out proteins that fall short.

💼 Transparency is a priority. While I may include affiliate links, my opinions are never for sale.

🔍 My goal is to keep things simple, clear, and direct so you can feel confident and fully informed with every review you read.

📖 MyProtein The Whey Review Details

When reviewing MyProtein The Whey, I prioritized transparency, quality, and value—three areas where this protein powder falls short. Despite marketing itself as a premium product, The Whey raises major red flags: a lack of an amino acid profile, inflated BCAA claims, and questionable listing practices.

My analysis indicates that Whey is either amino-spiked or includes hydrolyzed collagen, a cheaper protein source that doesn’t offer the same muscle-building benefits as whey. If you’re wondering how many grams are necessary to stimulate muscle growth, research suggests that you need 15 grams daily over 8 weeks. 

While The Whey delivers decent mixability and updated flavors, these minor positives don’t outweigh the core issues. Suppose you’re looking for a reliable, high-quality protein. In that case, there are better options in MyProtein’s lineup, like Impact Whey Isolate and Clear Whey Isolate, which offer verified protein integrity. Ultimately, The Whey feels like a low-quality product marketed at a premium price—a choice I can’t recommend.

✅ Is MyProtein Legit?

If you’re on a budget, MyProtein is undeniably appealing for its affordable pricing. But the next question is, “Is MyProtein legit?” If you aim to increase your daily protein intake, the answer depends on which line of MyProtein protein powder you choose. Based on my analysis, MyProtein can be a great budget-friendly option—with the right product.

The biggest concern with MyProtein is transparency. For example, we still don’t know how much leucine per serving is in their protein powders. However, three MyProtein products are verified by Informed Protein as not amino spiked, which adds credibility. These options are:

• Impact Whey Isolate
• Impact Whey
• Clear Whey Isolate

If you follow one of these three lines, you’ll get a solid protein powder at a budget-friendly price. Just be mindful of the concerns about transparency and adjust serving sizes to meet your protein goals.

 💪 After Training Shake: How Many Scoops of The Whey Should You Take Post Workout?

If you plan to use MyProtein The Whey Vanilla Ice Cream as a post-workout shake, you’re likely wondering: how many scoops do I need to stimulate muscle growth? Research indicates that a minimum of 25 grams of protein and up to 3 grams of leucine is needed post-workout to stimulate muscle protein synthesis effectively.

Here’s what we know about MyPro The Whey:

• Each serving provides 25 grams of protein.
• Despite numerous attempts to obtain an amino acid profile, MyProtein has repeatedly refused to provide this level of transparency.

I strongly suspect The Whey is amino spiked, with added free-form amino acids or lower-quality protein sources to boost protein content artificially. As I outlined in my full review, I believe The Whey is a blend of leftover proteins from three of MyProtein’s other lines:

1. Impact Whey Isolate
2. Impact Whey
3. Hydrolyzed Whey Collagen

How Many Scoops Should You Take?

If mixing The Whey with water, I recommend using 1.5 scoops to ensure sufficient protein and leucine content for muscle recovery.

Prefer milk over water? Consider using high-protein skim milk. According to USDA data, one serving of high-protein skim milk provides:

• 13 grams of protein
• 1.3 grams of leucine

Combining one scoop of The Whey with high-protein skim milk can likely improve the total leucine quantity, making it more effective as a post-workout shake.

Final Note

While The Whey can technically meet post-workout protein requirements, its lack of transparency and potential quality issues make it less reliable than verified, third-party-tested protein powders. Consider alternatives like Impact Whey Isolate or other fully transparent protein options if you prioritize trust and efficacy.

🛒 Where To Buy MyProtein Products

The current price of MyProtein’s The Whey is $54.99 for 30 servings, which works out to $1.83 per serving. But here’s a tip: wait for a sale. MyProtein regularly offers steep discounts during flash sales, holiday promotions, or limited-time deals. I snagged a container for $31.87—bringing the cost down to $1.06 per serving.

• MSRP: $54.99 (30 servings, $1.83 per serving)
• Sale Price: $31.87 (30 servings, $1.06 per serving)

However, if you’ve read my full review, you’ll know that The Whey may not be the best value for your money. Between amino spiking concerns, ingredient transparency issues, and its premium price tag, you’re better off investing in a third-party verified protein like Impact Whey Isolate or Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey.

The Whey is exclusively available through MyProtein US, so don’t expect to find it on Amazon or other third-party retailers. To save, wait for a flash sale or a seasonal promotion before purchasing.

💸 Does MyProtein Have A Money Back Guarantee?

MyProtein US offers a 30-day return policy, but here’s the catch—it’s heavily geared toward apparel purchases. The terms and conditions do not mention refunds or returns for protein powders or other consumables.

If you encounter an issue with The Whey, your best action is to contact MyProtein US customer service directly. However, don’t expect an easy resolution, as their return policy lacks clarity regarding dietary products.

Price: 1 out of 10. Why such a low score? The Whey’s pricing doesn’t align with its value:

• No amino acid profile: Transparency concerns make it hard to trust the protein content.
• No third-party verification: Premium pricing without certifications to back quality.
• Ingredient transparency issues: The proprietary blends raise red flags about quality.

At its MSRP of $54.99, The Whey feels overpriced for what you’re getting. Its lack of transparency and quality concerns outweigh any perceived savings, even at a discounted price. Instead, spend your money on a verified, transparent, and trusted protein powder.

⚛️ Is MyProtein The Whey Amino Spiked?

The short answer? Most likely. MyProtein claims that The Whey provides 25 grams of protein and 3 grams of leucine per serving, but their lack of transparency raises questions. I’ve requested an amino acid profile for all of MyProtein’s protein powders, yet they fail to provide this level of transparency for their consumers. Rest assured, I leave no stone unturned in my review process to provide you with the most comprehensive and reliable information. 

While the product boasts “over 5 grams of naturally-occurring glutamine,” the description makes no such claim about leucine. This omission is telling. Based on industry norms, naturally-occurring leucine in a high-quality whey protein would be around 2.5 grams. Low-quality whey, which MyProtein is known to source, drops further to ~2.1 grams.

This leaves us with a significant discrepancy. To reach 3 grams, The Whey likely includes a minimum of 0.9 grams of added leucine or other amino acids. If I’m going to make an assumption, I believe the listed Hydrolyzed Whey Protein is from their Hydrolyzed Collagen. 

If you’re interested in non-amino-inflated MyProtein protein powders that Informed Protein has verified, here are your options and my full review of each product.

• MyProtein Impact Whey Isolate (Review, purchase from Amazon)
• MyProtein Whey Protein (Review not finished; purchase from Amazon)
• MyProtein Clear Whey Isolate (Review, purchase from Amazon)

🔬 MyProtein Whey Protein Content

MyProtein claims that the Whey delivers 25 grams of protein and 6 grams of total BCAAs per serving. While these numbers look impressive on paper, a closer examination suggests the values are artificially inflated through amino spiking. Amino spiking, protein spiking, or nitrogen spiking is a deceptive practice in which free-form amino acids are added to the protein powder to inflate the protein count. This can mislead consumers into thinking they’re getting more protein than they are. Is MyProtein using remnants of their Hydrolyzed Collagen Protein? I wouldn’t be surprised.

🧪 How Much MyPro The Whey is Truly Natural?

Protein testing relies on nitrogen content, which means free-form amino acids like leucine, glycine, or taurine can inflate protein numbers without adding complete protein. High-quality whey isolate contains about 10% leucine per gram of protein, which means:

25 grams of protein x 0.10 = 2.5 grams leucine per serving

However, lower-quality whey—like that used by MyProtein—contains around 8% to 9% leucine, providing:

25 grams of protein x 0.08 = 2.0 grams to 25 grams protein x 0.09 = 2.25 grams.

This puts The Whey’s naturally occurring leucine content closer to 2.1 grams per serving.

🧐 Where Does the Additional Leucine Come From?

MyProtein claims 3 grams of leucine per serving, but the gap between the naturally occurring leucine (~2.1 grams) and the claimed number (3 grams) suggests 0.9 grams of free-form leucine is added. This boosts the product’s perceived quality while artificially inflating its protein count. 

Additionally, MyProtein claims 6 grams of BCAAs per serving, but naturally occurring BCAAs for lower-quality whey would only provide ~4.5 grams. The remaining 1.5 grams is likely a mix of added leucine, isoleucine, and valine, further inflating the numbers.

💊  Amino Acids Used to Make Proteins

Free-form amino acids like glycine, taurine, and alanine are cheaper alternatives often used to spike protein powders. While MyProtein doesn’t disclose these, the inflated leucine and BCAA numbers raise questions about whether other nitrogen-rich amino acids contribute to the 25 grams of protein per serving. A more realistic estimate would reduce the true protein content to ~23 grams.

🛠️ Common Amino Acids Used for Protein Spiking

Here’s a list of amino acids and nitrogen-rich compounds commonly added to artificially inflate protein content:

1. Glycine: A cheap amino acid often used to boost protein claims but has minimal impact on muscle protein synthesis.
2. L-Taurine: Frequently added for its high nitrogen content and marketed as a focus or energy enhancer.
3. L-Alanine: A low-cost amino acid that offers limited benefits for muscle building.
4. L-Glutamine: Sometimes marketed for recovery, but its free-form addition primarily inflates protein counts.
5. L-Arginine improves blood flow but is often added to elevate protein values falsely.
6. L-Ornithine: Another nitrogen-rich amino acid with no major role in muscle building.

🛠️ Other Non-Essential Amino Acids

Non-essential amino acids like L-proline, L-serine, and L-citrulline are occasionally included in spiked products to increase nitrogen content without significantly contributing to muscle recovery or protein synthesis.

🛠️ Nitrogen-Rich Non-Amino Acid Compounds

In addition to free-form amino acids, some products include nitrogen-heavy compounds like:

• Creatine: While beneficial for strength, it falsely inflates protein content in lab testing.
• Beta-Alanine: Commonly added to pre-workouts but not effective as a protein substitute.

🛠️ Branched-Chain Amino Acids (BCAAs)

Even legitimate amino acids like L-leucine, L-isoleucine, and L-valine can be added in free-form amounts to inflate BCAA totals artificially. These are often used to boost a product’s perceived quality, as seen with MyProtein’s claimed 6 grams of BCAAs.

🆚 Comparing Whey Protein Powder: MyPro The Whey Protein

Understanding the potential for amino spiking in MyProtein The Whey highlights a key question: How does it stack up against other whey protein powders on the market? With its inflated leucine and BCAA claims, it’s critical to compare The Whey’s reported and adjusted values to transparent, high-quality brands like ON Gold Standard, MyProtein Impact Isolate, and Transparent Labs.

🆚 Comparing Protein Sources: MyProtein Whey vs ON Gold Standard

Our first comparison pits MyProtein The Whey against the widely acclaimed ON Gold Standard Whey. These two protein powders share similarities:

• A blend of three protein sources
• Proprietary enzymes to aid digestion
• Comparable nutrition profiles

ON Gold Standard the superior choice? Transparency, value, and no amino spiking makes it a winner in this first match. For an in-depth analysis, check out my detailed review of ON Gold Standard Whey, also available on Amazon.

Here’s how MyProtein The Whey compares to ON Gold Standard Whey head-to-head:

Comparison Metrics	MyProtein The Whey Vanilla Ice Cream	ON Gold Standard Vanilla Ice Cream
Leucine	3 grams (adjusted: 2.1)	2.6 grams
Leucine Percent	12% (adjusted: 8.4%)	10.83%
Total BCAAs	6 grams  (adjusted: 4.2g)	5.5 grams
Protein per Serving	25 grams	24 grams
True Protein per Serving	A high estimate of 23.9	24 grams
Carbs per Serving	3 grams	4 grams
Total Sugars	1 gram	1 gram
Calories	120	120
Serving Size	32.5 grams	31 grams
Number of Servings	31 servings	29 servings
Amazon Price	Not Available on Amazon	$39.04
Price per Serving	($48.99), $1.63	$1.34

🆚 Comparing Protein Sources: MyProtein The Whey vs Impact Whey Isolate

Which MyProtein powder stands out? If protein integrity is your top priority, Impact Whey Isolate is the choice. In my updated review (as of August 2024), I noted that Impact Whey Isolate is Informed Protein certified. Plus, it’s readily available on Amazon.

Here’s the comparison between MyProtein The Whey vs Impact Whey Isolate:

Comparison Metrics	MyProtein The Whey Vanilla Ice Cream	Impact Whey Isolate Vanilla Ice Cream
Leucine	3 grams (adjusted: 2.1)	Estimated 1.68 grams to 1.89 grams
Leucine Percent	12% (adjusted: 8.4%)	Esimated 7.6% to 8.6%
Total BCAAs	6 grams  (adjusted: 4.2g)	4.5 grams
Protein per Serving	25 grams	22 grams
True Protein per Serving	A high estimate of 23.9	22 grams
Carbs per Serving	3 grams	1 grams
Total Sugars	1 gram	1 grams
Calories	120	110
Serving Size	32.5 grams	25 grams
Number of Servings	31 servings	31 servings
Amazon Price	Not Available on Amazon	$35.99
Price per Serving	($48.99), $1.63	$1.16

🆚 Comparing Protein Sources: MyProtein vs Transparent Labs

In this showdown, MyProtein The Whey goes up against Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey. Transparent Labs sets itself apart with third-party testing by Ladboor. Labdoor is an industry recognized third-party protein certifier.

In my full review of Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey, I highlighted its strengths as a solid purchase, particularly for those prioritizing quality over cost. While Transparent Labs is priced higher per serving, its verified protein integrity, lack of amino spiking, and higher protein content per serving make it a standout choice. Plus, Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey is readily available on Amazon, offering fast shipping for Prime members.

Here’s how MyProtein The Whey stacks up against Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey:

Comparison Metrics	MyProtein The Whey Vanilla Ice Cream	Transparent Labs Protein French Vanilla
Leucine	3 grams (adjusted: 2.1)	2.8 grams
Leucine Percent	12% (adjusted: 8.4%)	10%
Total BCAAs	6 grams  (adjusted: 4.2g)	5.9 grams
Protein per Serving	25 grams	28 grams
True Protein per Serving	A high estimate of 23.9	28 grams
Carbs per Serving	3 grams	1 gram
Total Sugars	1 gram	1 gram
Calories	120	120
Serving Size	32.5 grams	34.3 grams
Number of Servings	31 servings	30 servings
Amazon Price	Not Available on Amazon	$53.99
Price per Serving	($48.99), $1.63	$1.80

📜 Is MyProtein 3rd Party Tested?

Yes and no.

While MyProtein adheres to NSF safety, cleanliness, and quality standards, not all its products undergo independent third-party testing for protein integrity or banned substances. Informed Choice and Informed Protein certifications do not verify MyProtein The Whey for amino spiking.

Additionally, only two MyPro The Whey flavors—chocolate Peanut Butter and Blueberry Muffin—carry the NSF certification.

Amino Spiked Rating: 1 out of 10. After repeated requests, MyProtein declined to provide an amino acid profile, leaving the impression that The Whey is a mix of protein remnants (concentrate, isolate, and hydrolysate) combined with branded enzymes and added amino acids. This will be discussed further in the Ingredients Section.

🥤 How to Make A MyProtein The Whey Protein Shake

Here are the instructions for preparing a MyProtein The Whey protein shake:

1. Add 1 scoop of The Whey to 6–8 fluid ounces of water or milk.
2. Use a MyProtein Shaker for the best results.
3. Consume immediately.

However, MyProtein forgot to include one critical step: shake vigorously after adding the powder to the liquid.

How Does MyProtein The Whey Mix?

The Whey performs as expected when mixed with other MyProtein US powders. It mixes smoothly, with only the occasional clump if you’re rushing. For most users, the ease of mixing will meet their expectations, especially when they need a quick, hassle-free post-workout shake.

🥄 Does MyPro The Whey Come With A Scoop?

Yes, MyPro The Whey comes with a scoop.

Mixability: 9 out of 10. If you’re in a hurry, The Whey’s mixability won’t disappoint you. It’s simple, efficient, and gets the job done.

⚖️ Does MyProtein The Whey Protein Powder Come With A Scoop?

Yes. MyPro The Whey comes with a scoop.

📋 What Are The Ingredients In MyProtein The Whey Vanilla Ice Cream?

Here is the ingredient list found in MyProtein The Whey Vanilla Ice Cream. 

MyPro The Whey Ingredients	Description
Whey Protein Isolate, Concentrate, Hydrolyzed Whey	Main protein sources in MyPro The Whey
Natural & Artificial Flavoring	Flavor enhancers
Salt	Flavoring
Xanthan Gum	Thickening agent
Sucralose	Zero-calorie artificial sweetener
Acesulfame Potassium	Zero-calorie artificial sweetener
Aminogen Proteases	Proprietary enzyme; (from Aspergillus niger and Aspergillus oryzae) that helps break down protein, improving digestion and absorption.
Cellulose Gum	Anti-caking agent
BC30 (Bacillus coagulans GBI-30 6086)	Proprietary probiotics enhance protein absorption.
Digezyme Multi-Enzyme Complex	Proprietary enzyme; aids in breaking down protein, carbohydrates, and fats, improving overall digestion.

🔍 MyPro The Whey: Proprietary Ingredients Meaning

MyPro The Whey offers three proprietary ingredients. Let’s take a brief look at all three and there effectiveness.

🦠 BC30 Cultures

BC30 is a probiotic strain aimed at improving gut health. Specifically, it features GBI-30, 6086, a strain shown to survive the stomach’s harsh acidic environment and help digest milk proteins. This strain has been studied for its potential to enhance nutrient absorption and immune support, making it a useful addition for individuals who consume whey regularly. 

However, while BC30 may improve gut health, it is limitedly relevant to muscle recovery or protein synthesis—the core concerns of most protein powder consumers.

💊 Aminogen

Aminogen is a patented enzyme blend claimed to aid protein digestion. Despite being used in supplements by brands like Herbalife since the early 2000s, it lacks substantial peer-reviewed scientific evidence to support its effectiveness.

This lack of verification raises doubts about its inclusion in high-quality products. Without robust data, Aminogen feels more like a marketing tool than a functional ingredient, especially when compared to verified digestive aids like lactase or protease enzymes.

🧬 DigeZyme

DigeZyme is a proprietary blend of enzymes that claims to aid in the digestion of macronutrients—proteins, carbohydrates, and fats. While enzyme blends like this can benefit those with mild digestive issues or sensitivities, their necessity in a whey protein product is questionable. Including DigeZyme may indicate that MyPro The Whey undergoes high-heat processing, which can denature proteins and make them harder to digest. 

This enzyme blend could help offset some discomfort for individuals with lactose intolerance or digestive sensitivities, but for most users, it’s a redundant addition to a properly processed protein.

🌍 Does MyPro The Whey Use USA-Sourced Whey?

No, MyPro The Whey uses internationally sourced whey, contributing to its lower price point than competitors. Where exactly does the whey come from? While MyProtein has not disclosed specific sourcing details, discussions on Reddit suggest the whey may come from India, a region known for cheaper dairy production.

This transparency undermines consumer trust, especially those prioritizing high-quality or locally sourced products.

Ingredient List: 7 out of 10. The ingredient profile of MyProtein The Whey raises red flags about quality and transparency:

• Using proprietary ingredients like Aminogen and DigeZyme suggests using high-heat filtration, which can denature protein and compromise digestibility.
• While BC30 may support gut health, its impact on protein absorption and muscle recovery is indirect.
• Reliance on proprietary blends without solid scientific backing highlights a focus on marketing over efficacy.

Ultimately, MyProtein The Whey prioritizes flashy additives over delivering a reliable, high-quality protein, falling short of expectations for a premium-priced product.

🥗  Nutrition Facts for The Whey

Here are the Nutrition Facts for The Whey, Vanilla Ice Cream.

Nutrients	Amount per Serving
Serving Size	32.5 grams
Calories	120
Total Fat	1 gram
Sodium	160 milligrams
Total Carbohydrates	3 grams
Dietary Fiber	0 gram
Total Sugars	1 gram
Protein	25 grams; likely amino spiked. (A high estimate of 23.9 grams)

🍗 Protein Percentage per Serving in MyProtein The Whey Protein

Here are the flavors offered by MyProtein The Whey Protein and their protein percentage per serving. 

Vanilla Ice Cream: 25 grams of Protein per Serving / 32.5 gram serving  = 77% Protein per Serving
Chocolate Fudge: 25 grams of Protein per Serving / 32 gram serving = 78% Protein per Serving
Caramel Popcorn: 25 grams of Protein per Serving / 32 gram serving = 78% Protein per Serving
Chocolate Pudding: 25 grams of Protein per Serving / 32 gram serving = 78% Protein per Serving
Cookies & Cream: 25 grams of Protein per Serving / 32 gram serving = 78% Protein per Serving
Chocolate Peanut Butter: 25 grams of Protein per Serving / 27.9 gram serving = 90% Protein per Serving
Blueberry Muffin: 25 grams of protein per serving / 27.9 gram (estimate) = 90% Protein per Serving

Average amount of protein per serving for all flavors: 81% Protein per Serving

Let’s now take a peak if I experienced any digestive issues drinking MyProtein The Whey Vanilla Ice Cream.

🍨 Is MyProtein The Whey Lactose-Free?

The Whey is not lactose-free. However, if you’re gluten-intolerant, It is a gluten-free protein powder. I did not experience any major bloating or GI distress.

Nutrition Facts: 7.0 out of 10. I firmly believe The Whey is an amino-spiked protein powder. Upon examining the protein percentage per serving, the numbers appear unrealistically high, raising concerns about its authenticity. This protein powder is likely either amino-spiked—artificially inflated with free-form amino acids—or enriched with MyProtein Hydrolyzed Collagen, a lower-quality protein source.

Both scenarios need to be revised. Amino spiking inflates protein content without delivering the full benefits of a complete protein, while hydrolyzed collagen lacks the essential amino acid profile required for muscle building.

👌 The Whey Protein Review: Does The Whey Taste Good?

If it wasn’t clear already, I purchased the Vanilla Ice Cream flavor of MyPro The Whey.

When paying a premium for protein powder, the expectation is that the taste will be exceptional—something that genuinely reflects the flavor advertised. In this case, The Whey Protein doesn’t deliver. The packaging doesn’t show a decadent cone of vanilla ice cream but rather a simple color profile of vanilla, which is fitting because that’s about all you get.

You’ll be disappointed if you’re hoping for a ticket to Flavor Town. The flavor is marginally better than cheap protein powders, but I’ll go as far as to say that some budget-priced options taste better. Recognizing customer feedback, MyProtein has launched updated versions of Chocolate Fudge and Vanilla Ice Cream flavors and introduced a collaboration with Jelly Belly to revamp its flavor lineup.

Final Verdict: Only use the original versions of Chocolate Fudge and Vanilla Ice Cream if you want a subpar experience for a premium price. If you’re set on trying The Whey, opt for the updated flavors or a collaboration flavor—but even then, the value for the price may leave you underwhelmed.

Let’s now turn to MyProtein reviews on Amazon to see what other customers say.

⭐️ MyProtein Whey Amazon: MyProtein Review

For transparency, The Whey is just a mix of leftover remnants from other MyProtein products. MyProtein offers Impact Whey Isolate (an isolate) and Impact Whey (a concentrate), but where does the third protein source in The Whey—hydrolyzed whey protein—fit? Interestingly, the only hydrolyzed product MyProtein offers is a hydrolyzed collagen protein, which raises questions about the true integrity of The Whey’s formulation.

Regarding flavor, The Whey’s options are remarkably similar to those offered for Impact Whey Isolate and Impact Whey. However, The Whey is currently unavailable for purchase on Amazon, so customer reviews remain limited to other MyProtein products. Let’s dive into the Impact Whey Isolate reviews.

💪 MyProtein Whey Amazon: Impact Whey Isolate Review

Impact Whey Isolate holds an impressive 4.3 out of 5-star rating. Here’s what customers love about it:

• Easy to mix: Minimal clumping for smooth shakes.
• Affordable: Great protein-to-price ratio.
• High protein content: Delivers on macronutrient claims.
• Third-party verified: Certified for protein integrity.

However, it’s not all positive. Here are the cons:

• Specialty flavors have a questionable taste: Some flavor profiles miss the mark.
• Transparency issues: Packaging inconsistencies have led to outdated, uncertified batches.
• Poor packaging: Leaky seals or flimsy materials.

For the best experience with Impact Whey Isolate, stick to these flavors: Chocolate, Vanilla, Salted Caramel, or Unflavored. Specialty flavors are hit or miss.

💪 MyProtein Whey Amazon: Impact Whey Review

Moving on to Impact Whey, this product has earned a 4.3 out of 5-star rating from over 11,000 reviews. Customers highlight these positives:

• Great taste: A satisfying flavor profile across the basics.
• Affordable: Excellent value for everyday use.
• Easy to mix: Smooth consistency with minimal effort.
• Third-party verified: Certified for protein content and integrity.

The negatives include:

• Overly sweet: Some flavors may taste cloying to sensitive palates.
• Digestive issues: Reports of bloating or stomach discomfort.
• Packaging issues: Similar complaints as with Impact Whey Isolate.

Transparency remains a recurring issue with MyProtein’s flagship products. Customers have noted receiving older, uncertified packaging before implementing the Informed Protein certification.

For flavor recommendations, the standout options are Vanilla, Chocolate, Salted Caramel, and Chocolate Brownie. Unflavored also gets consistent praise, but it needs flavor.

Let’s go ahead and wrap up this MyProtein The Whey Review with a recap of the major points. 

🏁 MyProtein The Whey Review – Final Thoughts

After a deep dive into MyProtein The Whey, it’s clear this protein powder doesn’t live up to its premium price. Here are my three summary points for this MyProtein The Whey Review:

1. Lack of Transparency and Potential Amino Spiking
   The Whey raises serious red flags. MyProtein fails to provide an amino acid profile, making verifying claims about leucine, BCAA content, and ingredient transparency impossible. We have a product that hints at potential amino spiking. This lack of transparency makes it hard to trust, especially compared to third-party at similar and cheaper price points.
2. Overpriced for the Quality Offered
   At $54.99 for 30 servings, The Whey is a premium product. But falls flat on delivering value and transparency. With no detailed formulation disclosure, its price tag feels unjustified. Even with frequent discounts, the cost doesn’t compensate for the lack of transparency or quality.
3. Better Alternatives Are Available
   While the Whey has decent mixability and updated flavors, its value is underwhelming, for those seeking high-quality protein powders, Impact Whey Isolate, Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey, or other verified brands offer superior transparency, efficacy, and protein integrity without the same concerns about amino spiking or quality shortcuts.

So, with all the facts laid out, the big question remains: Is MyProtein The Whey worth it? Let’s break it down.

🤔 Is MyProtein The Whey Good?

MyProtein has built a reputation for offering budget-friendly supplements, but is The Whey a protein powder worth adding to your post-workout routine?

No.

The primary issue here is transparency—or lack thereof. MyProtein doesn’t disclose an amino acid profile or offer detailed information about the formulation of The Whey. On the surface, its nutritional profile might seem comparable to ON Gold Standard Whey, but the difference boils down to trust. ON Gold Standard provides clear ingredient sourcing and transparency, while The Whey leaves too many unanswered questions.

I firmly believe The Whey is an amino-spiked protein powder. If it isn’t amino spiked, the hydrolyzed whey protein it includes is likely hydrolyzed collagen—a lower-quality protein source that doesn’t deliver the same benefits for muscle recovery.

Ultimately, The Whey fails to meet the standards of a trustworthy, high-quality protein powder. With so many options in the MyProtein lineup, it’s time to answer the ultimate question: Which MyProtein protein powder truly stands out? Let’s break it down.

🏆 Which MyProtein Protein is Best?

If it’s unclear, MyPro The Whey is not a good protein powder. However, if you’re still considering a MyProtein product, let’s be honest—MyProtein powders are budget-friendly. So, which one should you choose?

You’re in luck—I’ve reviewed two other MyProtein powders: Impact Whey Isolate and Clear Whey Isolate (Lemonade flavor).

• Best Tasting: If flavor is your top priority, MyProtein Clear Whey Isolate is the best-tasting protein in their lineup.
• Best Protein Per Serving: For a product with a higher protein content per serving, go with MyProtein Impact Whey Isolate, especially if lactose-sensitive.
• Best Value: If you’re looking to save a few dollars and are not lactose-sensitive, MyProtein Impact Whey is a solid option.

My Ranking of MyProtein Powders (Based on Protein Per Serving):

1. Impact Whey Isolate (buy from Amazon)
2. Impact Whey (buy from Amazon) 
3. Clear Whey Isolate (buy from Amazon)
4. MyPro The Whey

One more thing to consider if you’re hesitant about making a MyProtein purchase:
Impact Whey Isolate, Impact Whey, and Clear Whey Isolate are all certified as not amino spiked by Informed Protein. I firmly believe MyProtein uses low-quality whey in its products, likely with a leucine content of 8%–9% per gram of protein. You must increase your serving size to meet the optimal leucine threshold for muscle growth.

In summary, while MyProtein powders are affordable, you should choose carefully based on your goals and nutritional needs. Avoid MyPro The Whey and stick to the more reliable options like Impact Whey Isolate or Clear Whey Isolate for better results.

Are you looking for more protein reviews? Here are all of JKremmer Fitness unbiased protein powder reviews. Are you looking for a protein review that I haven’t done yet? Email me at my ‘Contact Me’ page, and I’ll do my best to get an unbiased review out in 4 weeks. 

🧐 MyProtein The Whey Review Round-Up

Category	Score
Value	1 out of 10
Amino Spiking	1 out of 10
Shakeability Test	9 out of 10
Ingredient List	7 out of 10
Nutrition Facts	7 out of 10
Overall Score	25/50, 50%, Save Your Money

📑 Sources

Allied Medical Training. (2024, July 19). Amino Spiking: Ensuring Your Protein is Truly Clean – Allied Medical Training. https://alliedmedtraining.com/amino-spiking/

Bischof, K., Moitzi, A. M., Stafilidis, S., & König, D. (2024). Impact of Collagen Peptide Supplementation in Combination with Long-Term Physical Training on Strength, Musculotendinous Remodeling, Functional Recovery, and Body Composition in Healthy Adults: A Systematic Review with Meta-analysis. Sports Medicine. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-024-02079-0

Chandel, N. S. (2021). Amino acid metabolism. Cold Spring Harbor Perspectives in Biology, 13(4), a040584. https://doi.org/10.1101/cshperspect.a040584

Gorissen, S. H. M., Crombag, J. J. R., Senden, J. M. G., Waterval, W. a. H., Bierau, J., Verdijk, L. B., & Van Loon, L. J. C. (2018). Protein content and amino acid composition of commercially available plant-based protein isolates. Amino Acids, 50(12), 1685–1695. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00726-018-2640-5

Innophos. (n.d.). Aminogen® Advanced Enzyme Blend | Innophos. https://www.innophos.com/ingredients/nutrition-brands/aminogen-advanced

Science and Research – BC30. (2021, July 8). BC30. https://bc30probiotic.com/science-and-research/

Stark, M., Lukaszuk, J., Prawitz, A., & Salacinski, A. (2012). Protein timing and its effects on muscular hypertrophy and strength in individuals engaged in weight-training. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 9(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/1550-2783-9-54

Stoppani, J. (2018, June 23). Protein powder problems. Jim Stoppani. https://www.jimstoppani.com/supplements/protein-powder-problems/

USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference Legacy. (2018). Nutrient content in household measure. https://www.nal.usda.gov/sites/default/files/page-files/leucine.pdf

What is BC30TM – BC30. (2022, March 25). BC30. https://bc30probiotic.com/what-is-bc30/
Wolfe, R. R. (2017). Branched-chain amino acids and muscle protein synthesis in humans: myth or reality? Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 14(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12970-017-0184-9